Or perhaps there is, but he is ignorant, or weak, or mean” (p.4) She thinks God must not care her because God lets her suffere. So she claims that “ perhaps there is no God. In fact, she believes there maybe no God exists. She thinks Miller simply would be communication to his omniscient God for what God already knows, thereby wasting God’s time and his time. First, Weirob claims, “how in the world does a prayer help?” (p.2) to raise the debate of good, evil and the existence of God. Weirob does not believe in God, so she does not admit Miller to pray for her. Dialogue of Good, Evil, and the Existence of God by John Perry In John Perry's book Dialogue on Good, Evil and the Existence of God, he used three characters in the dialogue in order to clarify the positions of the three characters (Weirob, Miller, and Cohen), the arguments they provide in support their positions and the 'end state' of their. It seems that he is so helpful in this debate. He helps Weirob and Miller to figure out what is their own point of view all the times and also he raises some useful ideas to solve their arguments. Dialogue of Good, Evil, and the Existence of God by John Perry In John Perry's book Dialogue on Good, Evil and the Existence of God, he used three characters in the dialogue in order to clarify the positions of the three characters (Weirob, Miller, and Cohen), the arguments they provide in support their positions and the 'end state' of their. Therefore, he has to convince Weirob to believe there is possibility that God and evil are both exist in order to win the debate and also pray for her. He thinks evil and God can both exist in this world. Miller is a Christian who believes in God.
She wants Miller to proof there is possibility of his beliefs. She challenges with Miller’s belief and claims that there is no God exist. She thinks if God really exists in this world, then God is a monster (evil) because God lets her suffered. Weirob is a philosopher who is not a Christian. Perry shows a clear position of Weirob, Miller, and Cohen. This allows us to examine our understanding of the good, evil and the existence of God.
What emerges from these exchanges is a diversity of fruitful and innovative ways of thinking about God and evil, proving that the problem of evil is far from exhausted.In John Perry’s book Dialogue on Good, Evil and the Existence of God, he used three characters in the dialogue in order to clarify the positions of the three characters (Weirob, Miller, and Cohen), the arguments they provide in support their positions and the “end state” of their discussion. Eight prominent philosophers of religion have been invited to engage in critical but friendly dialogue, and to develop and contest both traditional and relatively unorthodox approaches. Dialogue on Good Evil and the Existence of God Book Description: John Perry-author of the acclaimed Dialogue on Personal Identity and Immortality (Hackett Publishing Co., 1978)-revisits Gretchen Weirob in this lively and absorbing dialogue on good, evil, and the existence of God. Buy Dialogue on Good, Evil, and the Existence of God (Hackett Philosophical Dialogues) online at an affordable price. This volume opens the way for a wholesale reconsideration of the problem of evil. In contemporary philosophy, however, the debate has petrified into a select number of entrenched and defensive strategies. One of those rare questions in philosophy that is not only technically recalcitrant but also engages the hearts and minds of the broad community is the so-called ‘problem of evil’: how can the existence of an absolutely perfect God be reconciled with the existence of suffering and evil? This problem has exercised the finest minds across the centuries, from ancient to modern times.